Riley and Joyce Pendergraph held title to their Gilroy, California, home in the NHuss Trust.
The trust sold the home and reported no taxable gain, on the strength of $286,070 in claimed improvements.
On audit, the IRS found only $56,284 of improvements. The court was more generous and allowed $82,039. That left $101,907 of taxable capital gain.
Notice what the court did: It did not hold the Pendergraphs to the $56,284 the IRS could document. Instead it estimated, which courts may do in select circumstances when a taxpayer clearly incurred costs but cannot prove the exact amounts. That estimating doctrine is nearly a century old, and it is a consolation prize, not a winner.
The estimate still cost the Pendergraphs tax on $101,907, and they had to go to court and litigate to that lower amount.
By not taking time to gather the right documents, the Pendergraphs saved themselves a few hours. Work out the hourly rate on that bad decision.
For decades, most sellers never had to prove basis because the $250,000 and $500,000 home-sale exclusion amounts swallowed the entire gain. That is no longer a safe assumption, and it gets less safe every year.
Congress set those two numbers in 1997 and never indexed them for inflation. The median home price then was around $129,000.
Today it runs in the $400,000s, and the Case-Shiller national index puts the increase since 1997 at roughly fourfold. The National Association of Realtors estimates that more than 13 million homeowners would exceed the exclusion if they sold.
Congress has proposed home-sale legislation to double the $250,000/$500,000 and index them for inflation, and in alternate legislation to eliminate the caps entirely. None have been enacted.
Key point. Plan on $250,000 and $500,000 as the exclusions.
You can no longer count on the exclusion covering your entire gain. For a growing share of long-tenured homeowners, every documented dollar of basis is a dollar that escapes tax at 15 percent (18.8 percent with the net investment income tax, or NIIT) or 20 percent (23.8 percent with the NIIT).
A $60,000 kitchen you cannot prove can cost you real money.
Start with what you paid to buy the property, including title insurance, transfer taxes, recording fees, legal fees, surveys, and owner’s title charges from the settlement statement.
Then add improvements over the years, special assessments for local improvements such as sidewalks or sewer lines, amounts spent restoring property after a casualty, and the cost of bringing utilities to the property.
An improvement adds to the value of the home, prolongs its useful life, or adapts it to new uses. A repair simply keeps it in working order. Replacing the roof is an improvement; patching it is a repair.
An improvement counts only if it is still part of the home when you sell. Replace the windows you replaced 20 years ago, and the first set drops out of basis. You include only the cost of the second set in basis.
The deck that came with the house does not enter the equation. You add the cost of the replacement deck to basis. The original kitchen you gutted does nothing, but the cost of the remodel adds to basis. Track what came out, not just what went in.
Basis is a two-way street. You can’t ignore the subtractions.
Casualty losses you deducted and insurance reimbursements you received come off. So does depreciation you claimed, or could have claimed, on a rental period or on a home office after May 6, 1997. The depreciation comes back as unrecaptured gain taxed at rates up to 25 percent.
Energy credits come off as well. The credits you claimed in earlier years reduce the basis of the improvements that generated them. For example, solar panels installed in 2023 with a 30 percent credit add to basis, but only net of that credit.
You need to prove two things about every improvement: (1) what you bought, and (2) that you paid for it. The law requires you to keep records sufficient to establish both.
Almost no one receives a cancelled check anymore. Your bank shows you an image, and most institutions purge those images on their own schedule, commonly after around seven years. Basis records on your home routinely have to survive 30 years, so do not assume the bank will be holding your proof when you need it.
Download the check images when the payment clears, and file them with the invoice. Paper is not required. Records may be kept in an electronic storage system, provided the system is legible, indexed, and capable of reproducing a complete and accurate copy. A scanned invoice in a properly organized folder is as good as the original.
For each project, keep four things together:
1. The contract or proposal.
2. The final invoice showing what was actually done.
3. Proof of payment.
4. A few dated photographs. The photographs do great work because they establish that the improvement existed and when.
Not three years. The usual IRS audit assessment period runs three years from filing, but that clock starts on the return reporting the sale, not on the return for the year you built the deck.
So the rule is: keep basis records for as long as you own the home, plus the limitations period after the year you sell it. A 1998 receipt is live evidence on a 2030 sale of your home.
The home purchase and improvement process produces records for your permanent tax file.
And when you sell and buy again, the file does not close. Keep the old file until the statute runs its course, three tax years after the sale year. Start a file for the new house the day you close.
Try this filing system, which might take you 15 or so minutes each December:
- One folder, saved in the cloud and backed up locally, named for the property and its purchase year.
- One file per project. Name each project, with date, vendor, and amount. Include the contract, the invoice, proof of payment, and photos.
- One running spreadsheet listing date, description, amount, and whether the item is still part of the house.
- A closing folder holding the settlement statement from the purchase.
- A note of any energy credit, casualty loss, insurance payment, or depreciation claimed, with the year and the amount.
Measure this easy system against a tax bill measured in tens of thousands of dollars. You are paying yourself very well for this minimal documentation time.
1. Death of a spouse. The decedent’s interest takes a new basis at date-of-death value. In community property states, the entire property gets stepped up to fair market value. Either way, the reset reduces how much of the old record trail still matters. But now you need a new record with documentation of the date-of-death value.
2. Divorce. A transfer of the home between spouses or former spouses incident to divorce carries over the transferor’s basis. The records travel with the property, so make sure you get them at the settlement rather than discovering later that your ex has the receipts.
Here are five takeaways from this article:
1. Improvements reduce taxable gain only to the extent you can prove them. A court may estimate the cost of your improvements, but you will pay tax and legal fees to find out what the court thinks. You can bet the court will do little to help you here because it has a rule to bear heavily against the taxpayer with failed records.
2. The exclusion amounts have not moved since 1997 while prices have roughly quadrupled, so basis records now matter to millions of sellers who once could ignore them.
3. Track subtractions as carefully as additions. Casualty deductions, insurance proceeds, depreciation, and energy credits all cut basis.
4. An improvement you removed or replaced no longer counts. Your spreadsheet should reflect this.
5. Download check images and store records electronically. Keep everything for as long as you own the home, plus the limitations period after the sale.